Here's the difference — all facts verified through public records.
Scroll here
This site was created by concerned residents to tell the whole truth about Aisha Wahab's record as an elected official. All facts have been verified through public records — official committee analyses, the Governor's veto messages, the Secretary of State, and the organizations' own published scorecards.
Every reason below is drawn from the public record — bill texts, committee votes, the Governor's veto messages, official scorecards, and news reporting — and linked to its source.
As chair of the Senate Public Safety Committee, Wahab backed amendments to SB 1414 (2024) that softened the original bill — so soliciting a 16- or 17-year-old stayed a misdemeanor instead of the automatic felony its author proposed. She then voted for the amended version.
“Alexandra's Law” (SB 44) and SB 62, which would have increased penalties for fentanyl dealers, stalled in her committee. CBS News reported she stood and walked out while Laura Didier — whose son died of fentanyl poisoning — was still delivering her testimony.
Wahab authored SB 403 (2023) to add caste to California's anti-discrimination law. It divided South Asian communities — the Hindu American Foundation condemned it as targeting Hindus — and Gov. Newsom vetoed it on Oct. 7, 2023, calling it “unnecessary.”
On the California Chamber of Commerce's 2025 “Best Business Votes,” she sided with the Chamber just 2 of 20 times — its lowest tier. The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association gave her a “D.”
A 2024 recall effort — driven by anger over SB 403 and her public-safety record — fell short of the signatures needed to qualify. Organizers blamed a defect in the state's official petition forms, a missing circulator-signature line, that invalidated thousands of signatures.
Wahab's SB 466 (2023) would have rolled back the Costa-Hawkins Act to allow rent control on far newer buildings. It drew just 15 of the 21 votes needed and failed — with fellow Democrats declining to supply the margin.
Wahab co-authored (with Sen. Scott Wiener) SB 1031 (2024), which would have let regional officials seek voter approval for taxes raising up to roughly $1.5 billion a year. It cleared the Senate 26–10 before the authors shelved it amid backlash.
During the 2026 CA-14 race, a complaint filed with the FEC alleges Wahab's state Senate committee improperly routed about $60,000 — including corporate donations — to support her congressional run, which federal law would not permit. Wahab denies it and calls it “political retribution”; the FEC has made no finding.
In an August 2026 interview, Wahab said the U.S. should pursue diplomatic engagement with Afghanistan “regardless of which group is in power.” The Taliban is sanctioned by the U.S. Treasury as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist, and the U.S., Canada, France and Australia have all withheld recognition of its government.
The Senate Public Safety Committee is the mandatory first stop for almost every criminal-justice bill in the California Senate — sentencing, drug crimes, firearms, corrections. A measure that fails or is never scheduled here dies for the session, no matter how much support it has elsewhere.
That makes the chair a gatekeeper. Senator Wahab has chaired the committee since 2023. In 2023, as fentanyl deaths were peaking, several tough-on-fentanyl bills stalled here — some killed not by “no” votes, but by Democrats, including the chair, simply declining to vote. Other crime bills did advance and were signed; the penalty-increase bills are where the pattern shows.
SB 44 — named for Alexandra Capelouto, 20, who died in 2019 from a fentanyl-laced counterfeit pill — would have warned convicted dealers they could face murder charges if a later sale killed someone. Backed by police chiefs, DAs and grieving parents, it failed twice in 2023 when the committee's Democrats declined to vote.
CapRadio ↗SB 62, which would have increased penalties tied to fentanyl quantities, was supported by district attorneys and the state Sheriffs' Association — and stalled in the same committee in 2023. An Orange County sheriff wrote an op-ed blaming the panel for blocking fentanyl bills.
Sheriff's op-ed ↗In 2024 the committee she chairs amended Sen. Grove's SB 1414 — over the author's objection — to narrow felony penalties for soliciting 16- and 17-year-olds. Public outcry led to it being strengthened again.
Sacramento Observer ↗She is a principal co-author of SB 747 (Wiener), which creates new state civil liability for certain federal law-enforcement and immigration actions. Sheriffs, police chiefs and PORAC oppose it, warning it could sweep in local officers.
See the bill record ↗Statewide trends during Senator Wahab's tenure as Public Safety chair — the environment in which those bills stalled. They reflect national and statewide forces, not the actions of any single legislator.
In fairness: overall violent and property crime fell statewide in 2024, and property crime reached multi-decade lows. This context is here because public safety and fentanyl were among CA-14 voters' top concerns during these years — not to attribute any trend to Senator Wahab.
A clear pattern emerges from the official committee analyses: law enforcement backed the crime bills that stalled or were narrowed in her committee, and opposes the liability bill she co-authored.
The California Police Chiefs Association and District Attorneys Association supported SB 44; DAs and the State Sheriffs' Association supported SB 62. Both stalled in her committee in 2023.
SB 62 committee analysis ↗The Police Chiefs Association and State Sheriffs' Association both supported SB 1414 — the bill her committee amended over the author's objection. No law-enforcement group opposed it.
SB 1414 committee analysis ↗The State Sheriffs' Association, Police Chiefs Association and PORAC — with 30-plus law-enforcement groups — oppose SB 747, warning it would expand officers' litigation risk.
Senate Judiciary analysis ↗A CalMatters / Digital Democracy investigation documented how at least 15 bills — including fentanyl measures — died in 2023 not by “no” votes, but by legislators declining to vote.
CalMatters ↗Independent scorecards from the groups themselves — her published ratings across her Senate tenure.
Our view: a near-perfect record with labor and advocacy groups — and a “D” from taxpayers — in a district built on small business and innovation. (The California Chamber of Commerce does not publish a per-legislator percentage score.)
As author of SB 403, Senator Wahab spent a year on a bill that divided her own community, was declined by the AAPI Legislative Caucus, and drew some of the largest Capitol demonstrations of the session — only to be vetoed by Governor Gavin Newsom.
“This bill is unnecessary. California already prohibits discrimination based on … ancestry … Because discrimination based on caste is already prohibited under these existing categories, this bill is unnecessary.”
The same approach shows up across her housing and tax agenda: introduce a sweeping bill, generate a headline, and watch it get pulled, paused, or killed.
SB 466 tried to roll back the Costa-Hawkins Act to allow rent control on far newer buildings. It lost a Senate floor vote 15–16, was sent to the inactive file, and died in 2024 — during a housing shortage.
SB 1031, the “Connect Bay Area Act,” she co-authored with Sen. Scott Wiener, would have authorized a regional tax estimated to raise roughly $1.5 billion a year for transit. It passed the Senate 26–10 before the authors paused their own bill on May 31, 2024 amid backlash.
SB 460 would have barred most landlords from asking about an applicant's criminal history. She pulled it before its first committee hearing; it never got a vote and died in 2024.
Her rent-cap push was sent to a task force rather than a vote amid a procedural clash with the mayor. During a contentious police-budget debate, the police chief called the council “ignorant,” then publicly apologized. Source ↗
Three of her bills were vetoed by her own party's governor, her rent-control and transit-tax bills were pulled or paused, and — as Housing Committee chair — she was publicly overridden (“rolled”) by her own committee on a major housing bill. CalMatters ↗
Congress requires building consensus, delivering results, and making difficult decisions on the issues that affect every family — including public safety.
This site quotes public records, official committee analyses, the Secretary of State, the Governor's veto messages, and the organizations' own published scorecards, each linked to its source. Pending complaints are identified as such; crime statistics are statewide context, not attributed to any individual.
Every factual claim above traces to a primary or reputable source.